West Haymarket Future Design Framework Historic Preservation Commission Comments
Essential Elements -
The pedestrian connections between the new West Haymarket (West) and the
historic Haymarket District (Hist) should be easily located from the Hist but
should not become an extremely dominant visual element to the Hist district.
Although it is not appropriate to design new buildings within the West area
which match or pretend to look like historic structures from the Hist area,
the restrained, contemporary use of some Hist materials (ie. paving, wall
surfaces, perhaps site furniture etc.) may be appropriate as a subtle reference
to the overall historic context of the site on which the West structures are
being located.
*In the Hist district, to meet the stated intent (promise) of 'temporary
parking' when the grassy median (on-axis south of the Post Office) was nearly
eliminated to accommodate the existing additional on-street parking ... this
central grass median should have the parking removed and the median restored
to turf or approved alternate landscape material(s).
*In the Hist district, the brick-surfaced diagonal parking located in-front/east
of the Train Station, (south of the median in item c, above) should
be redesigned and rebuilt to eliminate the very awkward elevated curbed 'meter
islands' in deference to an entirely 'street level' brick paving at the parking
meter locations. This would allow for improved use of this brick 'mall' as an
exterior event location.
Prohibitions
Because of their scale and mass, the new West buildings must not loom
visually over the Hist district like a large thunderhead about to burst,
especially as the public enters the Hist district looking west from the higher
elevation of 9th Street. This probably implies the greater building mass of the
new structures be located at the western edge of the new West site versus a
location near the existing train station et. al. along the east edge of the new
West site.
As referenced in Essential Elements item b. the new West buildings may draw
reference materially, texturally and in scale from the Hist district to the east,
but the new sturctures must not attempt to replicate the historic architecture
and details of the Hist area.
Confirming earlier commitments, no vehicular traffic associated with events
or activities in the new West buildings may pass thru the Hist district for
access.
All lighting in the West area, from street, parking lot and pedestrian
lighting to potential outdoor video screens should not allow spill-over light to
spill into the sky (ie. Respect for DarkSkys). In general the lighting in the
new West area should not create a halo of light above the Hist area.
Key Steps
The example used in the initial March 7 e-mail was good: "...at the conceptual
and scematic design stages of this project, review/comment must be conducted
with both the Urban Design Committee and the Historic Preservation Commission.